Binance VS Poloniex: Crypto Exchange Comparison
IMPORTANT: As of Nov 1 2019, Poloniex is no longer available for trading for U.S. Customers!
What are the quality metrics to which a crypto exchange should cling to? How are traders’ needs addressed and translated into acceptable performance measures by these platforms? Most often what these traders are hunting for are exchanges that offer reliability, safety and the insurance of their funds, a good choice of cryptocurrencies, support for fiat-to-crypto exchanges, low trading fees, and decent customer support.
The challenges to meet all these requests are tough, so a platform that manages to satisfy all of them at once is a rare find. Each one of them excels at something different, so when making your choice you need to examine a couple of them closely and compare their advantages to your investment strategy. You have a great choice of crypto exchange comparison guides on our website to get you started.
Today, we’re dealing with two rival exchanges – Binance and Poloniex. Although Poloniex used to be among the top platforms for crypto trading, recent bugs and their show of negligence towards their customers have brought the platform down on the lists. Binance, on the other hand, seems to enjoy a peak in its popularity among traders. Let’s find out why!
About the Exchanges
Binance is a recently developed crypto exchange platform, founded in 2017 in Shanghai, China. Not very long after, the company relocated its headquarters to Japan, due to regulatory issues. This country proved to be even less crypto-friendly, with the Japanese Financial Service Authority (JFSA) constantly breathing down Binance neck. The founder Changpeng Zhao, a Chinese national better known as CZ, transferred the company to Malta where they’ve settled down for good.
Malta is considered to have one of the best regulatory laws for crypto trading. Over there, Binance is regulated and complies with the recently enacted Virtual Financial Assets (VFA) Acts by the Maltese government. Apart from that, it hasn’t been registered with any other legislative boards. This doesn’t make the platform any less reliable since it adheres to anti-money laundering regulations and employs safety precautions for which it has won the trust of its target audience.
CZ, the driving force behind the team of experts hired at Binance, is an experienced marketer who used to work for Blockchain.info on various projects from the crypto industry. He also did a great job as a chief technological officer at OKCoin. This gave him the confidence to launch a crypto exchange on his own.
Poloniex is a US-based digital platform founded in 2014 that allows you to buy, sell, and trade with cryptocurrencies online. It was launched by Tristan D’Agosta who, together with the team, operated from Wilmington, Delaware.
Judging by his profile, no one would associate D’Agosta with the founder of a tech startup. He obtained a degree in Music at Rutgers, the State University of New Jersey, and worked for a while in a company called Polonius Sheet Music and as a freelance composer on the side. He is also a published poet. Once he entered the crypto sphere, it seemed like he has found his one true calling.
In 2016, Poloniex became one of the first exchanges to offer support for Ethereum. The new digital asset made a boom on the market and as a result, the trading volume of the company skyrocketed and so did its reputation. During the following year and a half, it was common to see Poloniex on the list of top exchanges.
But that’s not all! In 2018, Circle, the Goldenman Sahs-backed payment company, bought Poloniex in a $400 million deal. The idea was to make the exchange the first fully-regulated platform in the US, and in order for that to happen, Poloniex began a process of delisting some unreliable cryptocurrencies. However, after the buyout, the activities of the company have somehow slipped under the radar. By 2019, the only talks circulating about Poloniex were complaints about lack of customer support.
Binance VS Poloniex: The Comparison
Binance and Poloniex have a similar way of managing cryptocurrency exchanges. Both platforms support crypto-to-crypto exchanges and offer a great many coins to choose from. You get to buy, sell, and exchange not only the most mainstream coins like Bitcoin and Ethereum but a lot of lower-cap tokens too. Binance is famous for the huge number of trading pairs. To be sure that the currency you have can be paired with your target one, check out the full list of pairs per coin on CoinMarketCap.
However, neither of the two platforms supports trading with fiat currencies. This is a major stumbling block to investors, especially to those who are engaging in crypto trading for the first time. If they don’t have any digital coins, they would have to use another platform to convert their USD or EUR, or other fiats, before heading over to Binance or Poloniex.
Binance is starting to make some positive changes in this respect. Two days ago, the platform announced on their website that it now offers deposits and withdrawals of EUR, RUB, UAH and KZT. Users can deposit these currencies to their digital wallet via credit cards and bank cards. This is a partnership with Advcash, so you can also use their Advcash Wallet. This has some limitations too, as users also need to prove their eligibility by passing a simple KYC (Know Your Customer) verification test before Binance accepts their fiat request.
If you’re a resident of the US, you should have in mind that from September this year, Binance has launched Binance.us – the American trading desk of the company. The new platform is fully compliant to US regulatory laws. Those users who have funds left at Binance will be able to withdraw them for a little while longer but making trades and deposits is already disabled for US customers.
Binance uses the standard security measures such as online and offline storage, and the two-factor authentication making it harder for hackers to access both your email and mobile device to hack your account. The platform also has a withdrawal address whitelist where you can list IP addresses which will be allowed to withdraw funds from your wallet, blocking the ones that aren’t whitelisted.
In 2018, Binance introduced the Secure Asset Fund for Users (SAFU) which makes sure your funds will be safe in case of extreme security breaches. Binance allocates 10% of all trading fees received to SAFU. This is more than enough since the platform has one of the highest daily trading volumes. When Binance was hacked last May, the traders quickly got back the Bitcoins they lost thanks to SAFU.
On the other hand, you won’t read positive reviews about Poloniex when it comes to security levels. Apart from unsatisfactory customer support, the company was the victim of a couple of security breaches, the latest of which took place in May 2019. What happened was that Clams (CLAM), an obscure altcoin supported on the platform, witnessed a heavy price drop resulting in users losing around 1,800 BTC. They were exchanging CLAM for BTC when the flash crash happened, and it took 45 minutes before Poloniex froze the margin trading for the pair.
Immediately following the crash, Poloniex reimbursed only about 10% of the lost amount to its customers but announced, in a recent blog post, that they have decided to pay back the daily trading fee amount (in BTC) to the affected traders until their losses are fully recovered.
Binance is a true winner in this round! The platform offers some of the lowest trading fees that you can expect to see on the crypto market. Binance charges a fixed fee of 0.1% per trade, but if you use Binance (BNB) tokens to pay the transaction you get a discount, and the fee is slashed by half. If you hold BNB in your account, the trading fees will be subtracted from your BNB balance. This discount applies during the first five years, as well as some maker and taker discounts for a high trading volume.
Poloniex uses a volume-based maker and taker fee schedule which determines the trading fees by evaluating your trading volume over the past 30 days and checking whether you’re a maker or a taker. So, for example, if your trading volume is less than 600 BTC, Poloniex will add to your trade a maker fee of 0.15% or a taker fee of 0.25%.
You can’t really know if a platform appeals to you without checking out its website too. You don’t need to register to view the interface and the way they display price charts, trade history and trading options. Just open the website and click on the “View Exchange” button.
Binance has a pretty neat straightforward interface, and to make it even easier for you, they’ve created two interfaces: Basic and Advanced. If you’re a beginner, the first will make crypto trading less intimidating. If you already have some experience, challenge yourself with the Advanced interface.
If visual appeal is important to you, Poloniex definitely won’t be to your liking. It has an old-school interface and a somewhat cumbersome verification process. Unlike Binance, you will need to provide additional personal information to verify your account. If you are a resident of the US, you will have to give your social number too.
One of the advanced features of Poloniex that only a few mainstream exchanges offer is lending and margin trading. You can trade up to 10x leveraged orders, as opposed to Binance where you have a fixed rate of 3:1 (3x). For example, if you have 1 BTC, you’re allowed to borrow 2 more.
Binance does a great job in providing satisfactory customer support to its users. During these couple of years, there haven’t been any serious complaints and all user problems have been resolved promptly and effectively.
The website has an allocated Support section where you can fill in a request ticket and wait for an email answer. Expect to receive an answer within 24 to 72 hours which is the industry average. The best feature is the FAQ section with thorough explanations on everything crypto connected! From account managing to lesser used investment options peaking up on the market – the FAQ covers all this and more!
Things look far worse for Poloniex. The reason why the number of users has decreased so much overtime is not just the unreliable security measures but the poor customer support as well. After sending a ticket, customers wouldn’t hear from the company for months, sometimes waiting for as long as 90 days before their problem was addressed.
Both platforms are committed to providing their customers with an easy and convenient way of trading on their mobile devices. If you’re constantly on the go, download the app of Binance or Poloniex, available for both Android and iOS users.
Pros and Cons
- A great selection of tokens
- Now supports fiat currencies
- Very low trading fees
- An option to use BNB for a halved fee
- Has a Secure Asset Fund for Users
- Great transparency and responsiveness
- Mobile app for Android and iOS users
- Needs to invest more in fiat-to-crypto exchange options
- Has been hacked once
- A choice of 99+ altcoins
- Low trading fees and no deposit/withdrawal fees
- Two-factor authentication plus offline storage
- Offers margin trading up to 100x
- Has a mobile app
- Allows crypto-to-crypto exchanges only
- Serious problems with security and a flash crash in 2019
- Very slow support ticket responsiveness
We’ve come to the end of our guide and to what seems to us as an easy decision to make. We can all agree that the reputation of Poloniex is not how it used to be two years ago, so what will stop traders from choosing Binance – a platform that offers the same trading options and more!
When things started looking grim for Poloniex, users headed over to other crypto exchanges depending on their trading needs. Those who really cared for a big choice of cryptocurrencies switched to Binance or Bittrex. The real advantage of Binance is that it allows you to trade fiat currencies with some restrictions. Not only does it employ higher safeguarding measures, fund insurance, and great customer support, the platform has lower trading fees and a more user-friendly interface as well.
All Crypto Exchange Reviews
Cryptocurrency Exchange Comparisons
Exchange Versus Exchange Comparisons
Disclaimer: Digital currencies and cryptocurrencies are volatile and can involve a lot of risk. Their prices and performance is very unpredictable and past performance is no guarantee of future performance. Consult a financial advisor or obtain your own advice independent of this site before relying and acting on the information provided.