CFTC vs. SEC: Prometheum’s ETH Strategy Sparks Debate

Last Updated on March 7, 2024

Efe Headshot
Written by

Key Takeaways:

  • Prometheum’s initiative to offer Ether custody services has sparked a debate on whether Ether will be classified as a security by the SEC, potentially leading to regulatory conflicts with the CFTC.
  • CFTC Chair Rostin Behnam testified that both Bitcoin and Ether are considered commodities, emphasizing the potential regulatory implications of the SEC’s response to Prometheum’s actions.
  • Behnam called for legislative action to bridge the regulatory gap in the digital asset market, highlighting the challenges posed by the evolving cryptocurrency landscape and the need to preserve market integrity.

The Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) Chair Rostin Behnam has highlighted potential regulatory discord following a move by Prometheum, a broker-dealer registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), which may prompt the SEC to determine whether Ethereum (Ether) should be classified as a security.

This situation arises from Prometheum’s recent initiative to offer Ether custody services, a decision that if endorsed by the SEC, could signify Ether as a security, leading to a regulatory clash between the SEC’s and CFTC’s views on financial market regulations in the United States.

During a testimony before the House Committee on Agriculture on March 6, Behnam emphasized that both Bitcoin and Ether are considered commodities from the CFTC’s perspective.

The discussion on Prometheum’s actions revealed that this move was independently made by the firm, without direct endorsement from the SEC, thus raising questions on how the SEC will react to this development and its implications for Ether’s classification.

Behnam expressed concern that if the SEC takes any action to affirm Prometheum’s decision, thereby recognizing Ether as a security, it could create compliance challenges for CFTC-regulated entities, such as exchanges listing Ether futures contracts, as they would then be at odds with SEC regulations.

The CFTC chair also underscored the broader issue of maintaining market integrity and the longstanding classification of Ether as a commodity, a view that has supported the stable functioning of markets to date. He mentioned the ongoing challenges faced by regulators as the cryptocurrency market evolves, testing the boundaries of the current regulatory framework.

Chairman Rostin Benham testimony
Testimony of Chairman Rostin Benham. Source: CFTC

Behnam advocated for legislative action to address the regulatory gap in the digital commodity asset spot market, stressing that despite the absence of specific legislation, public interest in digital assets continues unabated.

About The Author

Efe Headshot
Written by

News Reporter

Efe Bravo, a seasoned journalist, delivers compelling insights into the cryptocurrency and blockchain industry.

His articles offer a deep dive into the latest trends, projects, and technological advancements shaping the future of digital finance.

Check Efe out on: